We explain the aberration amid assorted ancestors of Gorilla Bottle and its capital competitors: Sapphire glass, Dragontrail, and choleric glass.
Corning
Gorilla Bottle 6 has aloof been announced, appearance the latest adaptation of the accepted scratch-resistant bottle for smartphones and tablets.
The technology has been attention a advanced array of phones for years now, but it’s not the alone band-aid on the market. Dragontrail Glass, Sapphire, and choleric bottle are all accepted options. So how do they all alter from one another? Which one is best? We’ve got a few answers.
As the latest name suggests, Gorilla Bottle has gone through abounding iterations. The aboriginal bearing of the artefact launched in 2007, followed by Gorilla Bottle 2 in 2012 and Gorilla Bottle 3 in 2013. Best above flagships appear this year affection Gorilla Bottle 5, which aboriginal appear in 2016.
The basal action is the aforementioned for anniversary generation, application an “ion-exchange process.” This is about a deepening action area the bottle is placed in a ablution of aqueous alkali barometer 400 degrees Celsius (752 degrees Fahrenheit), according to its architect Corning. Potassium ions in the ablution actualize a “layer of compressive stress” on the glass, basically giving it added strength.
Gorilla Bottle 5 offers agnate blemish attrition to Gorilla Bottle 4, but is 1.8 times added abiding in bead tests, the company’s assembly ahead said. The bottle is additionally advised to bear drops from 1.6 meters, with the bottle captivation close about 80 percent of the time, according to Corning’s centralized tests. Meanwhile, Gorilla Bottle 4 was alert as acceptable to survive a bead analysis compared to Gorilla Bottle 3, but this was from a acme of one meter.
As for the latest adaptation of Corning’s product? Well, Gorilla Bottle 6 is agnate to Gorilla Bottle 5 in blemish attrition but is advised to survive assorted drops from alike greater heights. According to Corning’s columnist materials, it can survive, on average, 15 drops assimilate asperous surfaces from a acme of one beat and is up to “2x better” than Gorilla Bottle 5.
Asahi Bottle Co.
Made by Japanese behemothic Asahi Glass, Dragontrail is apparently the additional best accepted cast with manufacturers.
The aggregation uses a alleged float action to actualize its glass, sending aqueous bottle over a boiler of aqueous tin. Particles are afresh added for deepening afore the bottle is bound cooled and beatific for cutting.
Dragontrail Bottle comes in a few variants — Dragontrail, Dragontrail X, and Dragontrail Pro. 2016’s Dragontrail Pro is the latest product, delivering 30 percent bigger backbone adjoin angle drops acknowledgment to a angled bottle edge. Asahi adds that it should additionally bear added angle than accepted Dragontrail.
The cheapest band-aid of the lot, choleric glass, is the actual of best for abounding third-party awning protectors.
According to Scientific American, choleric bottle is aboriginal cut to admeasurement and afresh subjected to heating in a about-face oven. The bottle is acrimonious to aloof over 600 degrees Celsius (1,112 degrees Fahrenheit), followed by a bang of algid air for a few seconds.
The action makes the alien apparent of the bottle acknowledgment than the inside, which creates compression on the alfresco and astriction on the inside, giving us stronger glass.
Sapphire is the best big-ticket advantage on this list, which agency it’s mostly belted to abate $.25 like camera lenses and watch faces (including a few Apple Watch models).
According to a 2014 Pocketnow video, Sapphire screens are fabricated by agreement a Sapphire berry at the basal of a barrel. This butt afresh gets abounding with abridged corundum and extra uncrystallized Sapphire from antecedent batches. The butt is afresh put central a furnace, which heats the abstracts at up to 2,200 degrees Celsius.
The action takes from 16 to 17 canicule and after-effects in a 115-kilogram hunk of Sapphire. From here, a block is cut out for a smartphone display, afresh able and cut further.
JerryRigEverything
Which is bigger depends on what you anticipate is best important: blemish resistance, weight and thinness, affordability, appulse resistance, or a aerial antithesis of several of these. We use the Mohs calibration to admeasurement the blemish attrition of minerals and added agnate materials. A college cardinal on the calibration agency bigger blemish resistance, with talcum rated at one and architecture at 10. A actual with a college appraisement is additionally able of abrading a actual with a lower rating, such as a diamond-tipped aces abrading a quartz panel.
A third-party analysis by YouTub approach JerryRigEverything has apparent that Gorilla Bottle 5 can withstand actuality aching with picks as adamantine as bristles on the Mohs scale, so it’s fair to say Gorilla Bottle 5 (and apparently Gorilla Bottle 6) is at atomic a five. A Corning representative previously told us that all bottle avalanche amid bristles and six on the scale.
However, one industry antecedent claims Gorilla Bottle 4, Dragontrail Glass, and choleric bottle all allotment a acerbity of seven on the Mohs scale. Regardless, there doesn’t assume to a huge aberration in the scratch-resistance administration amid Gorilla Bottle 4 and Dragontrail Bottle (we’ll get to Sapphire in a moment).
Speaking of choleric glass, one adaptable alternation abundance claims it’s yet to see a choleric bottle protector appear safe afterwards a six or seven point aces scratching. Choleric bottle protectors are usually added scratch-resistant than plastic, however, which has a acerbity of between two and four on the scale.
Sapphire measures nine on the Mohs scale, aloof abaft diamond. So apprehend Sapphire-clad accessories to book bigger in your purse or active pocket.
Repair alternation UBreakIFix conducted a blemish analysis on both a Sapphire awning protector and Gorilla Bottle 5. The close acclimated a tungsten pick, which was rated nine on the Mohs scale. The Corning band-aid got scratched, but annihilation happened to the Sapphire protector.
Another way to admeasurement these abstracts is the Vickers acerbity test, which uses a diamond-tipped indenter to admeasurement a material’s acerbity (a college amount is better). Gorilla Bottle 5 has a Vickers acerbity of amid 601 and 638, according to Corning’s artefact sheet. Dragontrail architect Asahi Glass claims its bottle has a Vickers acerbity of amid 595 and 673.
There isn’t abundant aberration amid the two then, as there’s some cogent overlap. A attending at Sapphire’s acerbity appraisement added illustrates this point. Sapphire boasts a Vickers acerbity of over 2,000, with one abstraction putting it at about 2,700. In added words, Sapphire is atomic acceptable to be aching out of all these solutions.
Scratches are aloof one above allotment of the courage blueprint — drops are addition above challenge. Afterwards all, abounding bodies buy cases because of adventitious drops rather than accustomed scratches.
According to the beforehand UBreakIFix video, Gorilla Bottle can angle added during a four-point angle analysis than Sapphire. Sapphire adeptness be added scratch-resistant, but its adeptness to bear a drop-induced angle or anamorphosis isn’t as abundant as Gorilla Glass.
Corning
This aftereffect is echoed by Corning’s own “strength afterwards chafe damage” test, which tosses the bottle bedding into a butt abounding with assorted items and tumbles them for 45 minutes. Afterward, the bedding are removed and accountable to amount testing. Corning claims the Sapphire area bankrupt afterwards a amount of 161lbs (73kg) was placed on it, while its own band-aid withstood over 430lbs (195kg) of force. To be fair, it’s an centralized analysis of Corning’s making, but it’s still a absolute result.
Dragontrail architect Asahi hasn’t appear a four-point angle analysis video for its solution, alone assuming off a three-point analysis video from 2011 with up to 60 kilograms (132 lbs) of force applied. It’s not the ideal comparison, accustomed the differing analysis setups (and earlier bottle in the case of Dragontrail).
The abutting we get to an ideal allegory is a 2013 video by Corning, assuming Gorilla Bottle 2 and 3 faring bigger than an bearding competitor’s artefact (presumably Dragontrail).
Furthermore, clashing Gorilla Bottle 5 and its 1.6-meter survivability rating, Asahi hasn’t appear any specific acme ratings for Dragontrail Bottle appulse resistance. Instead, the aggregation alone says the angle of its latest Dragontrail Pro boasts 30 percent bigger backbone over the antecedent generation. Corning has previously claimed Gorilla Bottle 4 is up to alert as boxy in bead tests than battling articles (again, apparently Dragontrail).
Then there’s Gorilla Bottle 6, which is meant to bear assorted drops from greater heights. The aggregation claims its new bottle survives an boilerplate of 15 drops from one beat assimilate a asperous surface. Meanwhile, “alternative aluminosilicate glasses” breach on the aboriginal drop, according to Corning.
Corning
At this point, all above careful solutions are appealing boxy on scratches. Dragontrail and Gorilla Bottle assume to be analogously matched, while choleric bottle doesn’t assume to be far abaft at all. Sapphire has a delinquent advance over all three solutions but costs decidedly more.
In angle and appulse tests things get abundant murkier. There doesn’t assume to be abundant in the way of like-for-like testing amid Gorilla Bottle and Dragontrail. Alone one affair is for sure: Sapphire is analogously abhorrent for coil and dropping.
Corning’s 1.6-meter bead appraisement for Gorilla Bottle 5 is a big advance over Gorilla Bottle 4’s bead rating. And Gorilla Bottle 6 is alone improving, as it targets greater heights and assorted drops. Asahi’s blackout on bead tests suggests it’s backward behind, admitting it seems to be authoritative solid progress with folding displays.
What do you adopt in a affectation glass? Bigger blemish attrition or appulse resistance?
How are they made?
Which one is better?
What about angle or impact?
Conclusion
Gorilla Glass
Dragontrail Glass
Tempered glass
Sapphire
A awning protector fabricated out of choleric glass.
HTC appear a adaptation of the U Ultra with Sapphire glass.
Buy a stainless animate or bowl adaptation of the third-generation Apple Watch and you’ll get a Sapphire display. Apple
Best Samsung Galaxy S9 Awning protectors
Gorilla Bottle 6 pics: Imagine a absolutely customizable bottle aback with blush and texture
Gorilla Bottle and Dragontrail Bottle assume to be analogously boxy in the blemish attrition department
Sapphire adeptness be added scratch-resistant but Gorilla Bottle can angle added during a four-point angle test.
Comments
Post a Comment